Skip to content
Uplift the Brethren

Why did John deny being Elijah when Jesus said he was?

“John 1:21 records John's denial that he was Elijah, while Matthew 11:14 identifies him as the Elijah who was to come; are these statements contradictory?”

What this Answer covers

2 short answers drawn from 6 sermons and 2 articles by 5 preachers and writers across the brotherhood. Every answer links to the sources that teach it.

The full answer is a member benefit

Supporter ($25/yr) includes 3 full Answers of your choice, with their citations and source maps. Researcher ($50/yr) opens every Answer.

Sign in View membership

Related objections

  1. Is the Bible Full of Contradictions?

    “Skeptics circulate long lists of passages that supposedly contradict each other. If even one of them is a real contradiction, the Bible cannot be the word of a God who does not lie, so the honest thing is to admit the book is full of errors.”

More in Reliability of the Bible

  1. Can fallen people still repent and be forgiven?

    “How can passages saying some fallen people cannot be renewed to repentance be reconciled with passages affirming God's longsuffering and willingness to forgive those who repent and confess?”

  2. Did Mark name the wrong high priest when David ate the consecrated bread?

    “Mark 2:26 names Abiathar the high priest when David ate the consecrated bread, but 1 Samuel 21 names Ahimelech as the priest David approached. If Ahimelech held the office then, has Mark named the wrong priest or placed Abiathar in office too early?”

  3. Did Paul's Companions Hear the Voice on the Road to Damascus?

    “Acts 9 says the men with Paul heard the voice, but Acts 22 says they did not hear it. The same author contradicts himself about the same event, which shows Acts is not reliable history.”

  4. Did the centurion come to Jesus himself, or send Jewish elders and friends?

    “Matthew 8:5 says the centurion came to Jesus, but Luke 7:3-6 says he sent Jewish elders and then friends. How can these be accounts of the same event if one has the centurion speaking and the other has messengers?”